English Language--Study and Teaching--Fiction Friendshiip--Fiction School Stories (Grades K-3)

Negotiation: Persuading Miss Doover by Robin Pulver

To Jack, Samir is his best friend ever.

To Miss Doover, Jack and Samir together are nothing but trouble.

Jack offers to give Samir his whoopee cushion if he will sneak it into Miss Doover’s desk chair. And when Mr. Humphrey, the principal comes in to announce that the field trip is canceled, the two boys titter at Jack’s drawing of “Mr. Harrumphry.”

Mr. Humphrey is not amused at his likeness. Miss Doover is embarrassed at the behavior of her students.

Miss Doover sank into her chair, her head in her hands.

Pfffffffffftttttttpoooot!

Jack and Samir are re-assigned seats–on opposite sides of the room.

And the next day, when Jack tries to persuade Miss Doover to give them a do-over, she has an idea.

“Class, Jack and Samir have given me an idea! For today’s writer’s workshop, write a four-sentence persuasive essay.”

The brains of the kids are full of things to persuade their teacher to do–give them two hours of recess, a class pet, no more tests….

Samir hands his essay in quickly.

Miss Doover should not have confiscated the whoopee cushion.
Jack gave it to me.
I have a burning need to put it in my dad’s chair at home.

And Samir’s last sentence certainly nails his case:

Miss Doover doesn’t even like it.

Jack’s essay has only two sentences.

I’LL DIE IF I CAN’T SIT NEXT TO SAMIR.
People will be sobbing at my funeral.

Threats, bribery, and hyperbole don’t work: Miss Doover is NOT persuaded. Will the two best friends get the point of this lesson at last? In Robin Pulver’s latest. Persuading Miss Doover (Holiday House, 2018), Jack and Samir may be a little slow on the uptake, but young readers will laugh at the class’s first lame arguments for chocolate chips instead of raisins in the cafeteria cookies and how two-hour recesses will help them have fun learning–and thanks to Miss Doover’s persuasive efforts, the two partners in mischief do earn a do-over after all. Stephanie Roth Sisson’s classroom illustrations are spot on, and readers may actually have fun with this lighthearted lesson in writing and school behavior. Share this one with Pulver’s first book, Thank You, Miss Doover, in which Jack learns how NOT to write his great-aunt a thank-you note.

Great for fans of Margaret McNamara’s classroom story, How Many Seeds in a Pumpkin? (Mr. Tiffin’s Classroom Series). (see review here.)

Share this:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *